GM fish
The reproductive biology of fish is much simpler than that of mammals, so they are easier to genetically modify. Scientists have genetically modified about 35 different species of fish in the laboratory.
A genetically modified (GM) fluorescent zebra fish is being marketed as a pet in the USA, but currently there is no commercial production of GM fish as food. However, the company AquaBounty is seeking approval from the US Food and Drug Administration (FDA) to market GM Atlantic salmon in the US. The company proposes to ship GM fish eggs from its Canadian facility to Panama, for production in an on-land facility. The fish would then be trucked to the US for sale, as well as sold in Panama. In future, it plans to also sell eggs for production elsewhere.
The GM salmon includes a growth hormone gene from Chinook salmon (native to the North Pacific) and an anti-freeze protein gene from the ocean pout (native to the North West Atlantic). As a result, the transgenic fish produces growth hormone all year (rather than just during the warmer months) and reaches maturity faster than non-GM salmon.
There are concerns about the impact of GM salmon on wild salmon should it escape into rivers or the Atlantic ocean, because it could out-compete wild salmon for food, or breed with them producing offspring that may be less fit to survive. This could have serious negative effects on declining or endangered wild salmon populations. Although the eggs AquaBounty plans to produce will be all female and treated to produce sterile adult fish, this process is only up to 95-99% effective.
Recent Articles
Resources
- Consultation Responses
- Press articles
- The Independent: Warning over GM fish: hybrid salmon can breed with wild species and harm ecosystem (31st May 2013)
- BBC: GM salmon can breed with wild fish and pass on genes (29th May 2013)
- The PEI Guardian: Data on safety of P.E.I. salmon not there, warns expert (15th May 2013)
- Nature: Transgenic salmon nears approval (1st May 2013)
- Agra Net: GE salmon opponents warn of possible egg sales to U.S. customers (30th April 2013)
- The Guardian: GM salmon's global HQ - 1,500m high in the Panamanian rainforest (24th April 2013)
- Reuters: Genetically engineered salmon company expects U.S. regulatory OK in 2013 (23rd April 2013)
- Chicago Tribune: Whole Foods, others to shun genetically modified seafood (20th March 2013)
- Oregon Live: Oregon could ban genetically engineered fish, require labeling of genetically modified foods (18th March 2013)
- Phys.org: Activists fight FDA approval of AquaBounty's genetically engineered salmon (6th March 2013)
- Sky: Anti GM-Salmon Petition Nears One Million (27th February 2013)
- Globe Newswire: Intrexon and AquaBounty to Collaborate on Leveraging Synthetic Biology to Increase Productivity Across the Aquaculture Arena (15th February 2013)
- CBS New York: Genetically-Modified Salmon May Be Coming - With No Identifying Labels (4th February 2013)
- Anchorage Press: State house introduces anti-GE salmon resolution (31st January 2013)
- UpdatedNews: Genetically modified Salmon could soon be on your plate (22nd January 2013)
- Monterey County Weekly: Genetically modified super salmon tries to swim through a hole in the regulatory net (17th January 2013)
- Missoula Independent: Flash in the pan (10th January 2013)
- Voxy.co.nz: Approval of GE salmon 'a concern for NZ' (10th January 2013)
-
Food Navigator: AquaBounty Technologies CEO: Opponents have 'consistently and intentionally misrepresented the facts' on GMOs (9th January 2013)
Reports the view of Ron Stotish, AquaBounty's CEO.
- Boston Herald: Fishing for compliance (2nd January 2013)
- The Northern Times: Call to oppose US approval of GM salmon (28th December 2012)
- Food Poisoning Bulletin: FDA Moves Toward Approval of Genetically Engineered Salmon (26th December 2012)
- The Independent: This GM breakthrough could be the first of many (24th December 2012)
- The Independent: Ready to eat: the first GM fish for the dinner table (24th December 2012)
- Daily Mail: GM fish set for supermarket shelves after U.S. watchdog rules 'Frankenfish' is safe for environment (24th December 2012)
- The Telegraph: Super-salmon that are genetically modified to grow twice as fast a step closer to our dining table (24th December 2012)
- Spokesman: Trout Unlimited wary of genetically engineered salmon (23rd December 2012)
- Food Consumer: More worries over fast-growing genetically modified salmon (233rd December 2012)
- Grist: The apocalypse is here: FDA clears way for fast-growing GM monster salmon (
- KTUU.com: Alaska Delegation Fillets GM Salmon Report (21st December 2012)
- Yahoo News: Consumers Union Says FDA Assessment of GE Salmon Is Flawed and Inadequate (21st December 2012)
- Reuters: FDA moves closer to approval of GMO fish, critics outraged (21st December 2012)
- Slate: Is the White House Interfering With a Scientific Review? (19th December 2012)
- FT: Intrexon bids for the rest of AquaBounty (8th December 2012)
- Food Consumer: Is the fast growing AquAdvantage salmon safe to eat? (6th December 2012)
- Bloomberg: Fast-growing fish may never wind up on your plate (4th December 2012)
- ABC: AquaBounty Hoping to Serve DNA-Altered Salmon on US Plates (4th December 2012)
-
The Economist: Fish farming: High-tech breeders (3rd November 2012)
Reports high-tech non-GM approaches to fish breeding.
- Globe Newswire: Intrexon to Acquire 48% Stake in AquaBounty Technologies (31st October 2012)
- EcoWatch: Do You Want to Eat Genetically Engineered Salmon? (5th October 2012)
- U-T San Diego: FDA roadblock over modified salmon could sink company (13th August 2012)
-
ABC: Carp wars (22nd July 2012)
GM carp, intended to be used as a biological control measure to crash the population of wild carp, loses funding in Australia.
- Daily Mail: 'Frankenstein' meat could get go-ahead in EU: Safety fears over the use of GM animals (14th July 2012)
- Outside: The Genetically Engineered Salmon That Could Soon Run Wild (6th June 2012)
- FIS: AquaBounty still confident its transgenic salmon will be approved (4th June 2012)
- CBC News: Georgian businessman invests $8M in GMO salmon firm (29th May 2012)
- fishnewseu.com: Frankenfish still possible (25th May 2012)
- Alaska Native News: "Frankenfish" May Encounter Another Roadblock (17th May 2012)
- Boston Globe: Caught in troubled waters (20th February 2012)
- Fox News: Consumers want tougher FDA probe of engineered salmon (8th February 2012)
- International Business Times: Genetically Modified Salmon: What is it and is it Safe? (8th February 2012)
- FIS: Consumer groups petition FDA to classify transgenic fish as food additive (8th February 2012)
- California Progress Report: Bill to label GE fish fails in California legislature (25th January 2012)
- KeysNet.com: Release of genetically altered mosquitoes delayed (4th January 2012)
- Nanaimo Daily News: U.S. OK could see GE fish enter Canadian food supply chain (4th January 2012)
- NPR: Biotech Firms Caught In Regulatory No Man's Land (2nd January 2012)
-
Juneau Empire: Canada wraps up 3-day commission on salmon virus (1st January 2012)
Reports that an email that surfaced during the hearings revealed AquaBounty's Prince Edward Island facility in eastern Canada may have tested positive for Infectious Salmon Anemia virus, or ISAv in 2009. AquaBounty is the maker of AquAdvantage genetically engineered salmon.
- The Cordova Times: More concern voiced on genetically engineered fish (23rd December 2011)
- Times-Standard: Government should not be subsidizing GE salmon (21st December 2011)
- Food Navigator USA: Responsible approach to GM fish is to assume escape: Committee hearing (19th December 2011)
- Take Part: The Battle Over Frankenfish Heads to Congress (13th December 2011)
- NPR: Debating Genetically Modified Salmon (9th December 2011)
- PressDemocrat: GUEST OPINION: Halting federal funding of GE salmon (5th December 2011)
- Guardian: Obama administration 'bailed out' GM salmon firm (18th October 2011)
- Vancouver Sun: Safety of wild fish stocks questioned if GE salmon eggs hatchery gets OK (16th October 2011)
- TPM: FDA Decision Will Lead To First Ever Genetically-Modified Animal For Consumption (10th October 2011)
- Montreal Gazette: Tolerance for Frankenfish is falling: survey (5th October 2011)
- FishUpdate.com: New US Congressional bid to halt GM salmon (13th September 2011)
- The Guardian: Congress members seek to block approval of GM salmon (12 September 2011)
- Fairbanks Daily News: Murkowski to push ban on 'frankenfish' (8th September 2011)
- Science Daily: U.S. Government Urged to Rule On Consumption of Genetically Engineered Salmon (5th August 2011)
- Food Safety News: Congress, Public Not Fooled by Engineered Salmon (2nd August 2011)
- LA Times: FDA faces opposition over genetically engineered salmon (31st July 2011)
- Food Safety News: Big Salmon Says Science Is On Its Side (28th July 2011)
- Food Safety News: Lawmakers Tell FDA to Back Off on GE Salmon (18th July 2011)
- Time: Frankenfish: Is GM Salmon a Vital Part of Our Future? (11th July 2011)
- Grist: Genetically engineered salmon's fishy promises (5th June 2011)
- Law.com: A Biotech Fish Story (25th May 2011)
- Food Navigator USA: California Assembly votes to label GM fish (10th May 2011)
- Vancouver Sun: Fish Fight (23rd April 2011)
- Reuters: Europe scorns "supersalmon" as GM battle widens (22nd April 2011)
- Montreal Gazette: Genetically engineered fish could pose threat to wild stocks: DFO scientists (2nd February 2011)
- National Journal: Mark Begich's Salmon Run (17th February 2011)
- CBC: Genetically modified fish lawsuit threatened (20th December 2010)
- LA Times: Foes of GE salmon raise specter of 'Trojan gene' effect (26th November 2010)
- CBC News: GM salmon analysis a secret, groups complain (22nd November 2010)
- Truthout: Ban on Genetically Modified Salmon Proposed in Senate Despite Powerful Biotech Lobby (19th November 2010)
- EIN News: Genetically Engineered Salmon Plan Hit By Large Coalition of Critics (19th November 2010)
- CounterPunch: Here Come the FrankenSalmon (19 November 2010)
- CheckBiotech: Duke Analysts: FDA's transgenic salmon review too narrow (18th November 2010)
- CommonDreams.org: Biotechnology Industry Spends Over Half a Billion Pushing Controversial Projects like Genetically Engineered (GE) Food Animals (17th November 2010)
- Grist: What the FDA doesn't want you to know about GE salmon (12th November 2010)
- Food Safety News: Supersalmon: are they safe to eat? (9th November 2010)
- The Hill: Do not satiate appetite for salmon with GE products (26th October 2010)
- Macleans: Green eggs and ham (21st October 2010)
- The Hufington Post: Why Genetically Modified Salmon Affects My Rights as a Citizen (19th October 2010)
- Frederick News Post: Local minds made up over genetically modified salmon (16th October 2010)
- FishUpdate.com: Fierce debate opens up on GM salmon (14th October 2010)
- New York Times: Modified-Salmon Fight Showcases Risks, Rewards of Engineering Wild Species (7th October 2010)
- The Bioscience Resource Project: The AquaBounty Salmon: Will the World's First Commercial GE Animal Be an Albatross? (6th October 2010)
- Fish & Information Services: production of GM salmon set to begin (5th October 2010)
- Fairbanks Daily News Miner: Genetically modified salmon concerns Interior Alaska lawmakers (4th October 2010)
- FoodQualityNews.com: GM salmon assessment 'inappropriate', say Senators (30th September 2010)
- The Observer: GM food battle moves to fish as super-salmon nears US approval (26th September 2010)
- Medical News Today: We need more research on genetically altered salmon says FDA advisory panel (21st September 2010)
- Fish and Information Services: Experts urge to delay approving GM salmon (21st September 2010)
- Washington Post: Fears over modified salmon voiced (21st September 2010)
- Reuters: Biotech salmon leaves many questions (20th September 2010)
- ABC News: Surprise: FDA says scientific data on genetically altered salmon is unsatisfactory (20th September 2010)
- Puget Sound Business Journal: Seattle salmon farmers oppose frankenfish (20th September 2010)
- Anchorage Daily News: Alaskans line up against genetically engineered Atlantic salmon (10th September 2010)
- CBC News: Genetically modified salmon safe, FDA says (10th September 2010)
- Alaska Public Radio Network: "Frankenfish" scare Alaska salmon harvesters (9th September 2010)
- KMTR.com: Charleston fishermen opposed to genetically modified salmon
- The Independent: Fast growing salmon cleared as fit for human consumption in US (6th September 2010)
- Fish Information & Services: Aqua Bounty speaks out on GM salmon (14th January 2010)
- Fish Information & Services: Genetically modified salmon condemned (11th January 2010)
- FDA documents
-
FDA: Genetically engineered salmon
Includes links to all FDA documents, including the consultation on the draft environmental assessment.
- US Consumers Union: Labeling of Food Made for AquAdvantage Salmon (21st September 2010)
-
FDA: Public meetings on genetically engineered Atlantic salmon (September 19-21, 2010)
Includes links to public documents.
- US Consumers Union: Comments to FDA (16th September 2010)
- AquaBounty: Environmental Assessment for AquAdvantage Salmon (25th August 2010)
-
FDA: Genetically engineered salmon
- External links
- PR Watch: FDA Ready to Approve Frankenfish Despite Fishy Science (19th March 2013)
- Norwegian Develoment Fund: Genetically Engineered Salmon Fast-Growing Hype (30th January 2013)
- Friends of the Earth: "Fatally flawed" FDA assessment to unleash genetically engineered salmon (21st December 2012)
- Center for Food Safety: Obama Administration Snubs Risks, Moves Forward With GE Salmon Approval (21st December 2012)
- Friends of the Earth Press Release: Major U.S. Environmental Groups Call for Full Environmental Review of Genetically Engineered Salmon (8th November 2010)
- Letter to FDA from US environmental groups (8th November 2010)
- Center for Food Safety (US): GM fish
- Canadian Biotechnology Action Network: Biotech gets fishy with GM salmon (October 2010)
-
Alaska legislators letter to FDA (1st October)
Legislators in Alaska warn the FDA that "There is a very real fear that genetically modified salmon could wreak havoc on populations of wild salmon". They are also concerned about potential negative effects on the Alaskan economy, potential risks to public health and lack of rigorous scientific scrutiny.
- Oslo & Paris Convention (OSPAR): Background document for Atlantic salmon (2010)
-
ICSF Report: Aquaculture and its genetic resources (December 2009)
Includes sections on GM fish.
- Le Curieux-Belfond et al. (2008) Factors to consider before production and commercialization of aquatic genetically modified organisms
-
North Atlantic Salmon Conservation Organisation (NASCO): Williamsburg Declaration
NASCO states: "In view of the current lack of scientific knowledge on the impact of transgenic salmonids on wild salmon stocks, the use of transgenic salmonids should be considered a high-risk activity. There should be a strong presumption against any such use".
- Dunham (2004) Status of genetically modified (transgenic) fish
- WWF: The status of wild Atlantic salmon: a river-by-river assessment (May 2001)

